Skip to main content
Home
The Foodie Pilgrim

Main navigation

  • Home
  • What's on My Plate?
  • What's in My Glass?
  • What's on My Mind?
User account menu
  • Log in

Breadcrumb

  1. Home
  2. What's on My Plate?
  3. Recipes
  4. Dishes that include Seafood

Old Colony Club Clam Muddle

By John, 18 September, 2022
Region
New England
Description

"Clam Muddle"Here's another old Plymouth dish made with fresh local sea clams. This was served for many years at the venerable Old Colony Club in Plymouth.

It's not hearty like a clam chowder. This has no potatoes or other vegetables or meat in it, so it's not much for a lunch on its own.  It's a delicate soup course served rather like a consomme, to open a larger meal. I serve Clam Muddle in cups rather than in bowls.

Yield
8 Servings
Preparation time
15 minutes
Cooking time
10 minutes
Total time
25 minutes
Ingredients
1 q ground sea clams
2 c Clam Juice
2 T Butter (Unsalted)
2 T Flour
1 t cayenne
6 c Milk
Instructions
  1. Have three saucepans ready, the third big enough to hold everything.
  2. In one saucepan, heat the milk to scalding and keep it hot but do not let it boil. 
  3. If they are not ground, grind the clams. A grinder is better than a food processor for this. Save the liquid in a 2-cup measuring cup.
  4. If the measuring cup has less than two cups, add water to get to two cups. Bring it to a simmer in the second saucepan and cook the clams in it until just cooked, about a minute.
  5. In the third saucepan, cook the butter and flour into a roux. Add the cayenne, then stir in the clam mixture and return it just to the boil to thicken up a little. Remember that this is a soup, not a sauce.
  6. When the clam mixture has reached the boil, turn off the heat and stir in the milk. Serve immediately, with oyster crackers.
Source

Adapted from The Plimoth Colony Cook Book.

Book traversal links for Old Colony Club Clam Muddle

  • Oktapodi Krasato
  • Up
  • Oyster Stew

Explore our content

  • Recipes
    • Baked Goods and Sweets
    • Dishes that are Primarily Vegetables
    • Dishes that include Meat
    • Dishes that include Seafood
      • Ackee and Saltfish
      • Baccala Mantecato
      • Boiled Fish
      • Brandade de Morue
      • Cape Cod Fish Pie
      • Cape Cod Turkey
      • Capon Maggro
      • Cedar-Plank Salmon
      • Clam Pudding
      • Cod Baked in Tomato Sauce
      • Cod Baked in a Creamy Herb Sauce
      • Cod Baked with Lemon and Tomatoes
      • Cod Braised in a Ligurian Style
      • Cod Cheeks or Halibut Cheeks
      • Cod in a Bright Red "Infuocato" Sauce
      • Cod in a Fresh Green Sauce
      • Cod with Sage
      • Cold Poached Salmon
      • Cozze Tarantine
      • Egg Sauce
      • Escoveitched Fish
      • Fillets of Sole Bercy
      • Finnan Haddie
      • Fish Stock
      • Fish Veloute
      • Fishcakes
      • Forcemeat for Crab-Stuffed Sole
      • Frogmore Stew
      • Gamberi Dolceforte
      • Grilled Scallops
      • Haddock Baked with Potatoes
      • Haddock with Capers
      • Haddock with Leeks
      • Haddock with Shallot Sauce
      • Haddock with Snow Peas
      • Halibut in an Orange Sauce
      • Halibut with Clams in a Saffron Sauce
      • Halibut with Fennel Bulbs
      • Halibut with Herbs and Cherry Tomatoes
      • Irish Baked Salmon
      • Kabiljo
      • Kulebiaka
      • Lemon-Butter Cod
      • Lobster Cardinal
      • Lobster Salad
      • Lobster and Melon with Port
      • Lutfisk in Bacon
      • Mousse of Sole Cardinale
      • Mqualli
      • Mussels in White Wine
      • Mussels with Mushrooms, Parsley, and Chives
      • Octopus
      • Oktapodi Krasato
      • Old Colony Club Clam Muddle
      • Oyster Stew
      • Paupiettes of Sole Stuffed with Crab, with Lobster Cognac Sauce
      • Pistachio-Crusted Swordfish
      • Poisson a la Dieppoise
      • Poisson a la Parisienne
      • Rombo allo Spumante
      • Salmon on Root Vegetables
      • Scallop and Saffron Bisque
      • Shad Roe
      • Shrimp Marsala
      • Shrimp Tahiti
      • Shrimp al Forno
      • Shrimp in Orange Sauce
      • Sole Amandine
      • Sole Crusted with Almonds
      • Sole Oscar
      • Sole Piccata
      • Sole Poached in White Wine
      • Sole Rolled with Herbs
      • Sole in Cornmeal, Sauteed in Butter
      • Sole with Mushrooms
      • Sole with Peppers
      • Steamers (Classic)
      • Stuffed Sole in Saffron Sauce
      • Swordfish Provencal
      • Swordfish al Salmoriglio
      • Swordfish alla Ghiotta
      • Swordfish alla Messina
      • Swordfish in an Aromatic Tomato Sauce
      • Swordfish with Lemon and Capers
      • Trota del Nera
      • Trout Amandine
      • Trout Baked in Red Wine
      • Trout Baked with Thyme and Lemon
      • Trout with Mussels
      • Trout, Stuffed and Pan-Fried
      • Yankee Fish Cakes
    • Dishes that feature Eggs and/or Cheese
    • Risottos and Pasta Dishes
    • Sauces and Dressings
    • Seasonings and Condiments
  • Artisanal & Seasonal Foods and Mundane Ingredients
  • Feasts & Menus

Newest Recipes

  • Pasta al Limone
  • Neapolitan Beef Braciole
  • Pasta alla Gricia
  • Pasta all'Amatriciana
  • Pasta alla Napoletana
The Foodie Pilgrim
Powered by Drupal